Black salve / escharotic paste
Claimed for: Skin cancer
A corrosive paste sold as a way to "draw out" tumours.
01The claim
That a bloodroot and zinc chloride paste selectively destroys cancerous tissue and pulls the tumour out whole, leaving healthy skin untouched.
02Origin
Descends from nineteenth-century escharotic cancer treatments, revived through alternative-medicine mail order and, since the 2010s, sold heavily on social platforms with graphic before-and-after imagery. The dramatic scab that detaches is the marketing.
03Accounts
1 on recordParaphrased summaries of publicly circulating reports, not verbatim quotes from identified individuals. Unverified by definition.
“The scab came off with a mass attached and I thought that was the cancer gone. Eighteen months later it was in my lymph nodes. I needed facial reconstruction as well as treatment.”
reported harmReported 2019Consistent with dermatology and plastic-surgery case reports
04What's known
Zinc chloride is an indiscriminate corrosive. It has no ability to distinguish tumour from healthy tissue; the visible "tumour coming out" is a necrotic plug of whatever tissue the paste reached. Dermatology journals carry a steady stream of reconstructive case reports. The specific danger beyond disfigurement is that the surface wound heals over residual malignant cells, so a patient believes the cancer is gone while it progresses underneath, presenting later at a far worse stage.
Documented risk
A corrosive that destroys tissue indiscriminately. Causes disfiguring facial wounds, destroyed noses and ears, and lets cancer spread beneath an intact-looking scab.
Took this yourself? Add your account — including if it did nothing or caused harm.
Submit an account